It has now been four years since my wife and I decided to be ethically non-monogamous. It is something that I always felt drawn to. When she cheated on me and we got to the painful conclusion our relationship wasn’t working the way it was, it felt like the only way to continue in a fair way where we could both explore other people, fairly and with good communication.
Table Of Content
“I don’t care about the sex” I told her, and I really didn’t. I still don’t. But for how many people can sex be just sex? And how do you deal with a relationship style that asks you to confront your own insecurities so much more than regular monogamy while simultaneously dealing with a personality disorder that demolishes your confidence?
Our rules
We were in a resort in Spain when we decided to go ENM, as it’s called for short by the cool people. It felt really exciting at the time, like a world opening up. But we needed some rules to navigate this world. We didn’t want to create too many, but there was one important thing to me that would always be a guiding light: respect.
Respect means communication between not just me and my wife, but also our potential other partners. We also made a rule where she would not date other men alone until I felt comfortable, something that mostly had to do with residual doubts and shame coming from her infidelity, but also just from how sketchy a lot of men are.
The reality
Now, four years later, we have both faced the reality of being in the ENM scene, especially as neurodiverse people. The excitement is long gone, replaced by frustration for me. My rose-tinted glasses are off and I now realize that it’s just almost impossible for me to connect with people. We are on the apps but I struggle to get likes and if I do I just ghost them because I feel inadequate comparing myself to their profile. It’s like I want this but I also don’t.
ENM forces you into a lot of painful realizations and conversations. Especially as an insecure man, you’ll have to deal with watching your wife absolutely drowning in male attention while you yourself get a few drops in the desert. There were times where I wouldn’t get as much as a like a month. When you do finally connect, it’s hard. People on these apps have a certain communication style that just doesn’t work for me. I suck at small talk and flirting, especially through text.
So in the end we haven’t had much luck. In our four years, we have only had a few experiences. Today I want to go into those. The feelings, the emotions, the issues but also the good parts.
Experience(s) 1: Men
Men are easy. Men are plentiful. When you ask for a man to come fuck your wife, hundreds will come calling. And they did. The problem is that many men are sketchy as fuck. I remember one guy we invited over. He supposedly had a girlfriend that was ENM too. Once he was in our house he gave some weird vibes. His GF suddenly “wasn’t really active”, but he was very interested in my wife. He basically suggested that maybe I could go out of my own house so he could fuck her. We told him to fuck off. Months later, in the middle of the night on christmas, he sent my wife a desperate text.
This is a common thing. Men act like they’re part of a couple but the woman of the couple is never to be seen. She’s either “not active” or just an empty profile. The same goes for men changing their gender in the app to stand out from the crowd. Suddenly they’re “bi-gender” or “non-binary”, disrespecting people who actually identify with these genders just to get a desperate attempt at someone elses wife.
We did meet one nice guy. He talked to my wife for a bit and we agreed to try an MFM threesome for the first time. He came over, brought wine and we had a nice talk. He wasn’t creepy, he was respectful and then at the end of the night we just disrobed and had some fun. And then he left. No creepy texts, just wine and sex. We did it once more before never hearing from him again.
He was the exception to the rule though. Single men on these apps are overall disrespectful vultures.
Experience 2: Couple A
A year or so later we met a nice couple. We had a group chat going and everyone seemed to get along. So we invited them over, had some beers, ate some food, talked a lot. They were very sexually confident and open, unlike us at the time. It sounded freeing but it also felt a little intimidating.
At some point, we just started fucking I guess. I don’t remember how, it just happened. And it was nice. She was incredibly good at it too. It was the first time since we started that I got to fuck another woman, and it felt great. Just a few inches away, my wife was having her own fun. It was such a freeing feeling just watching each other enjoy others. Free, confident, trusting.
We had a group cuddle afterwards and it was the most loving feeling. It made me remember why we started this journey.
Unfortunately, the next day I fucked it up. The guy sent my wife a text and it triggered me massively. It brought back all the memories of the infidelity and the creepy christmas dude and I sent him a text in an emotional state where I really shouldn’t have. I broke a good thing and we never really spoke to them again. I don’t blame myself really, but I do wish things could’ve been different.
Experience 3: Couple B
Fast forward two full years. After our experience with Couple A, we kind of put things on the backburner. We tried here and there but we had our minds full with other stuff. This year, we’ve been a bit more active again. A few weeks back, my wife found another couple on the app. She was hitting it off with the guy and it kind of put pressure on me to connect with his wife. She was nice but her texting style was hard for me to deal with at times.
Then, just a week ago, we met in real life. They were in Amsterdam and so were we. We went out for dinner. She was beautiful and had the greatest smile, but she didn’t really seem to see me. He was into my wife, but we already knew that. He was nice to me too, respectful. Not an asshole at all. It’s rare. After dinner we went to the bar and we all got a little wasted. I started connecting a little more with her. Then we moved to a karaoke bar.
I was pretty drunk at this point and I suddenly see my wife and this other man kissing. She asks me if it’s okay and I give her a thumbs up. It’s truly okay, he’s a nice guy. I just feel a little sad because I feel rejected again. Suddenly, his wife kisses me. In a drunken haze we embrace and we kiss and it’s magical. It’s the first time I feel true connection with someone besides my wife in a long while.
The night goes on. We sing and dance and laugh and we end up outside in an alley, discussing what we’re gonna do. He wants to take it further but she’s still on the fence. We talk about it, all four of us, respectfully and it’s kinda nice. A little weird but nice. I tell the woman about my insecurities and she tells me hers and we kiss again. She tells me I’m beautiful and kind and it heals something in me. We decide it’s best everyone goes home at this point. It’s a magical night where I truly connect with another person alongside my wife and once again it reminds me why we got into this.
Now it’s a week later and I’m back home. They are still talking, she has ghosted me. I know it’s probably nothing and we might very well pick up where we left off next time we meet, but it hurts me nonetheless. It’s part of the game, really. By opening up to these experiences, you also have to let in the hurt and the rejection. It’s shameful, and I cannot deny that it’s hard for me to see how much easier my wife has it in this regard. She has so much more choice and her role is different, always being the object of desire while I always feel like I have to prove myself over and over, actively advertising myself and always competing with the countless other men for someone’s attention.
Regrets?
So here I sit with my fresh experience of connection as well as some fresh hurt and jealousy. These are all feeling that are impossible to avoid if you get into this. I knew this from the start and even though it has been very hard at times, I do not regret doing this and neither does my wife. It has not only taught us better communication between us two, it has also brought in beautiful connections and/or hot sex with other people that has been truly healing for my AvPD. In my head is a little evidence locker called “you’re not repulsive to women” that now not only contains experiences with my wife and one ex girlfriend but also with two other beautiful women. Those wouldn’t have ever been there if we stayed monogamous.
I’m only 34 and we’re getting better at this with each try. We’re also moving to a more populated area next year, so I hope things will be even better in the future.
AvPD & ENM
Of course AvPD makes this entire thing extremely difficult. That is also why I feel it can be incredibly therapeutic. I get that even having a wife is a rarity and that I may be like one of five peole on the planet doing ENM with AvPD, but it works. It lets you explore others while having the safety of your own partner alongside you. It certainly introduces a lot of doubt and insecurities, but it also allows for beautiful connections and affirmations that you’d normally never get access to.
What you do need is an understanding partner. Someone who agrees to take this at your pace and discuss every step with you, because your vulnerability needs to be handled carefully. Especially if you’re the male counterpart of a couple, this can turn very painful if you don’t do it fairly. There are plenty of horror stories of unbalanced ENM couples where the guy sits at home every weekend while his wife is out fucking other dudes. That’d kill me, truly. But ENM is more than that. You can do it however you want. We found what works for us, and while it’s still something that requires a lot of communication and introspection, it’s working and I don’t really see us ever going back to monogamy.
The biggest fear I have is that someday either my wife or I will meet someone special. With Couple B, we already had a bond that went beyond just lust, but that’s okay. You can have a deep connection without it turning romantic. But what if it does? It hasn’t happened yet, but we talked about it and agreed to immediately discuss it if this ever happens between either of us and an outside partner. It’s the best one can do. Of course this danger always lurks for monogamous couples too. In fact, it might do more damage to a monogamous couple.
Conclusions
From four years and really very little experience I’d say that ENM is definitely not for everyone. But if you’re like us and actually enjoy having tough conversations and pushing the relationship further beyong regular limits, it’s a lot of fun. We love swiping other couples together on the couch and there really is somethign magical about sharing a date together where you’re both getting some action. It’s an indescribable feeling that I wouldn’t have wanted to miss out on in my life.